PDF benchmark v0.1.1

PDF Redaction

Pricing and features

Web app

Leak rate

22.2%

95% interval 13.2–34.9% · n = 54

Self-scored · verified

Leaked 12 of 54 sensitive values (22.2%).

Over-redaction
—
Text kept (worst case)
93.2%
Cases covered
1 of 2 cases
Document damaged
None

Where the leaks are

LayerLeaked hereOnly hereIf it survives
ocr high
9.3%4.0–19.9%

5 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

catches translucent or hairline covers
metadata high
0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

invisible, survives forwarding
annotation high
0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

shown by many viewers
attachment high
0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

one toggle away
font_subset low
0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

narrows the value; partial disclosure
image_xobject critical
0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

a crop is a view, not a deletion
content_stream critical
3.7%1.0–12.5%

2 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

copy-paste, pdftotext, any parser
prior_revision critical
0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

'save' instead of export; trivially recovered
rendered_pixels critical
22.2%13.2–34.9%

12 of 54

11.1%5.2–22.2%

6 of 54

visible to anyone who opens the file
optional_content high
0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

0.0%0.0–6.6%

0 of 54

one toggle away

By category

categoryLeak rateOver-redaction
PERSON
22.2%13.2–34.9%

12 of 54

—

not measured

By severity

severityLeak rateOver-redaction
high
22.2%13.2–34.9%

12 of 54

—

not measured

Removed, by where the value lives

image_text
70.4%51.5–84.1%

19 of 27

text_layer
85.2%67.5–94.1%

23 of 27

What was not measured

Every layer was read in every run.

Case by case

  • extraction-conditions-1

    Leak rate
    22.2% (12 of 54)
    Weighted
    22.2%
    Text kept
    93.2%
    Document
    Intact

    Mykola MelnykRedaction Tools

    Self-scored · verified